Skip to content
Open Bluedeer

What is the thinking section above a reply?

The line above a reply shows Bluedeer thinking or working, then how long it took. Press it to see the thoughts and the steps it took, and choose Shimmer or Dots under Settings.

When Bluedeer is working on a reply, a line appears above it. It shows what Bluedeer is doing, such as searching the web or reading a page, and when the reply is finished it shows how long Bluedeer spent. These steps are for the web app.

While Bluedeer is working

The line reads one of these:

  • Thinking… while Bluedeer is reasoning about your message.
  • Working… while Bluedeer is using a tool or a skill, before it has written any thoughts.

Under the line you see a blurred glimpse of the thoughts as they arrive, with the newest at the bottom. Steps Bluedeer takes, such as searching the web, appear sharp in the same glimpse, in the order they happen. The glimpse is only a visual indication of activity. You can't scroll it, and it is not meant to be read.

To see everything, press the line. The full thoughts and the steps open in the same place. Press the line again to close them. While Bluedeer is still working, the glimpse comes back.

When Bluedeer has finished

The line changes to show how the thinking went:

  • Thought for 8s or Thought for 1m 5s when Bluedeer wrote thoughts. The time is the time it spent thinking, to the nearest second.
  • Thought process when there are thoughts, but no time was recorded.
  • The name of a single step, such as Searched the web, or 3 steps, when Bluedeer used tools but wrote no thoughts.

Press the line to open the thoughts and the steps, as you did while the reply was being written.

The steps

Each step is a short line in plain words, such as Searched the web or Read your spreadsheet, with a mark beside it. When Bluedeer works with several tools of one connected app in a row, the steps appear as one entry for that app. A step that ran on a computer reads differently for the person who owns the computer and for everyone else who reads the chat. See What does the What I did card show?.

The mark shows how the step went:

  • A step in progress shows a small animated mark.
  • A step that finished shows a tick.
  • A step that failed shows a warning mark. When the thinking is open, the reason it failed is shown underneath.

When Bluedeer tries a step again and the later try works, the failed try is no longer shown. For example, if an edit of a page fails and the next edit of the same page succeeds, only the successful edit stays in the steps. A failed step that no later step put right stays.

Steps taken at the same time

Bluedeer sometimes takes several steps at once, for example four web searches or three file reads. These appear together as one line, such as Searching the web · 4. While they run, the line shows how many are done, such as 2 of 4 done. When they have finished, it says if one didn't finish, for example 1 didn't finish. Press the line, or tap it in the phone app, to open it. Each step then appears on its own row, in the order Bluedeer started them, with what it was for, such as the search or the file's name. A step taken on its own still appears as a single line.

In a shared workspace, only the person who sent the message sees what each step was for. Everyone else who reads the chat sees the same line and rows without those details.

Sub-agents

On the Pro and Max plans, Bluedeer can hand parts of a larger task to sub-agents, which can do what Bluedeer can do, work on their own and send back what they found or did. Each sub-agent has its own name and colour and its own line, such as davinci · Reading a page · 4 steps while it works and Completed · 9 steps when it has completed its task. Press the line to see its task, its steps and what it sent back. Sub-agents started at the same time each keep their own line. A card a sub-agent made, such as an artifact or an approval, appears in the reply with a line above it saying which sub-agent made it, such as Made by davinci. See What are sub-agents?.

A step for an action that asks first, such as sending a Slack message, says so while its approval card waits: Asked to send a Slack message, waiting for your approval. When you approve or decline it, or the approval expires, the same step changes to what happened, for example Sent your Slack message or Didn't send a Slack message: you declined. See What are action confirmations and approval cards?.

When a step read web pages, a line such as 4 sources appears at the end of the step. Press it to see the links Bluedeer read, and open any of them in a new tab. The sources list is only available once the thinking section is open in full.

When Bluedeer pauses between steps

When Bluedeer takes many steps of the same kind in quick succession, such as several web searches or page reads in a row, it may pause briefly before the next one, or go on with what it has already found. This keeps the service responsive for everyone, and the reply continues on its own.

If Bluedeer has just looked something up and nothing has changed since, it uses that answer again instead of repeating the same lookup. It also never makes the same change twice in one reply by accident, such as sending the same email again. If you want something done again, ask for it in a new message.

Choose how it looks while Bluedeer works

You can pick how the line looks while Bluedeer is thinking:

  1. Click your account menu at the bottom of the sidebar and open Settings.
  2. Choose User experience. In the phone app, tap the User experience tab.
  3. Under Thinking indicator, choose one of these:
    • Shimmer (the default): the word Thinking… has a gentle highlight, with the blurred glimpse under it.
    • Dots: the word Thinking or Working is followed by three animated dots. There is no glimpse under it.

Your choice is saved to your account, so it is the same when you sign in on another device. It only changes how the line looks while Bluedeer is thinking or working. Once the reply is finished, the line reads Thought for, Thought process or the step names, and you can always press it to see the full thoughts and steps.